The I/S team was awarded a SSHRC Partnership Development Grant in 2021 to focus on the exploration of material belongings as a means of exploring Indigneous history. The project connects four Indigneous partners (Musqueam, Metlakatla, Sts'ailes, Métis Nation of Alberta) with materials analysis researchers from UBC and the University of Alberta to address Indigenous-led research questions through the exploration of materials held in repositories.
The study of material things and their relations to land- and seascapes is foundational to an archaeological understanding of the past and a key aspect of the description of Indigenous history within non-Indigenous domains. Indigenous communities in Canada have detailed knowledge of their pasts framed in Indigenous scholarship, legal systems, and governance. However, in many contexts (e.g. academia, jurisprudence, and government) patterns in material evidence from scientific enquiry carry considerable weight, often superseding Indigenous-held knowledge. This structural inequality contradicts Canada’s endorsement of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) and exists even when extant material evidence is incomplete, inaccurate, or inadequate. This is the core challenge to be addressed in this project: how can we evaluate and improve the analysis of patterns in materiality from archaeological contexts to better serve Indigenous and non-Indigenous use of such data for a more accurate understanding of history.
We approach this effort through an emerging partnership network of four Indigenous communities (xʷməθkʷəy̓əm [Musqueam], Sts’ailes, Metlakatla, and Métis) and four university labs (UBC’s Pacific
Centre for Isotopic and Geochemical Research [PCIGR] and Laboratory of Archaeology [LOA], the light isotope facility at Leicester, and UAlberta’s Institute for Prairie and Indigenous Archaeology
[IPIA]). Our approach is to collectively pursue questions posed by the Indigenous partners by drawing on archaeological materials from heritage repositories to which we will apply advanced geochemical and biomolecular assessments and spatial analyses.
This structure is build around four Research Nodes that focus on analysis of materiality, and three Connecting Nodes that explore larger foundational themes. Detail on each of these is available through the tabs on the left. Our work is directed by a series of questions posed by Indigenous communities to univerity lab-based researchers. These are:
- Question 1. xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam) to PCIGR-LOA (UBC): From where did our ancient ancestors procure exotic/foreign lithic resources?
- Question 2. Sts’ailes to PCIGR-LOA (UBC): From where did our ancient ancestors collect lithic resources within our territory?
- Question 3. Metlakatla to LOA ADαPT(UBC)-Leicester Light Isotope Laboratory: What is the archaeological evidence of resource management of fish in our territory?
- Question 4. Métis Nation of Alberta to Rupertsland Centre for Métis Research-Institute of Prarie and Indigenous Archaeology (UAlberta): How can the compilation and management of geospatial and geophysical archaeology data demonstrate the Métis presence throughout the Métis homeland?
The goals of this project are to 1) attempt to answer these questions aand, 2) to consider the best practices of equitable partnerships between Indigenous communities and universities as we do so. We are structured around the seven nodes as a result:
Research Question and Research Issue
|xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam) to PCIGR-LOA (UBC)||Sourcing obsidian/exotic trade||PCIGR: SS-LA-ICP-MS/XRF/Raman spectroscopy/XRD – geochemical characteristics and multi-proxy lithic sourcing||Aviva Rathbone (Musqueam); Rhy McMillan (VUB/PGIGR); Dominique Weis (UBC/PCIGR)|
|Sts’ailes to PCIGR-LOA (UBC)||Sourcing fine-grained lithics/resource management within territory||PCIGR: SS-LA-ICP-MS/XRF/Raman spectroscopy/XRD – geochemical characteristics and multi-proxy lithic sourcing||Morgan Richie (Sts’ailes/UBC); Rhy McMillan (VUB/PGIGR); Dominique Weis (UBC/PCIGR)|
|Metlakatla to LOA ADαPT(UBC)-Leicester Light Isotope Laboratory||Sourcing fish/resource management within/beyond territory||
LOA ADαPT: Zooms - proteomics species identification
LOA ADαPT: PCA DNA – genotypic mapping
Leicester: Light Isotope Mass Spectrometry – fish diet, marine ecosystem dynamics
PGIGR: SS-LA-ICP-MS/XRF – geochemical signatures and sourcing
|Stephanie Huddlestan (Metlakatla); Camilla Speller (UBC); Eric Guiry (Leicester)|
|Métis Nation of Alberta to Rupertsland Centre for Métis Research-Institute of Prarie and Indigenous Archaeology (UAlberta):||Material expressions of identity in space||
IPIA: GIS – material taxonomy mapping
IPIA: remote sensing – non-destructive mapping material patterns at archaeological sites.
|Natalie Kermoal (Rupertsland/UAlberta); Kisha Supernant (IPIA/UAlberta)|
|Reposiitory||Repository obligations and access||Archival and collections platforms – short- and long-term improved repository practices||Sue Rowley (UBC)|
|Data Managment and Sovereignty||Infrastructural challenges to knowledge co-production||Data-sharing and management platforms – improved capacity for knowledge co-production||Neha Gupta (UBC); Kisha Supernant (Métis/IPIA/ UAlberta)|
|Reflections and Evidence||Philosophical evlauations of knowledge co-production||Evaluation of structural challenges to partnership ambitions – improved partnership and knowledge co-production||Alison Wylie (UBC); Sue Rowley (UBC)|